The Manic Pixie Dream Gay Girl: How Robin's Sexuality Served Will's Coming-Out Arc, Then Got Discarded | by Beatrix Kondo
Long Reads | Part 2 | Upside Down Feminism
Robin Buckley came out in Season 3 to help Steve Harrington process rejection. The bathroom confession remains one of the show's most beloved scenes—Maya Hawke delivered vulnerability and terror in equal measure, capturing what it feels like to risk everything by naming yourself to someone who might destroy you for it.
Except the scene itself relies on lazy, harmful tropes. Robin comes out because the Russian truth serum forces her to confess, which is just forced outing repackaged as a plot device. Forced outing isn't funny, isn't cute, and reducing a lesbian woman's coming out to chemical compulsion is lazy, prejudiced, and misogynistic as hell. The show took one of the most vulnerable moments in a lesbian woman’s life and made it involuntary, stripping Robin of agency in the very scene meant to establish her identity. After all, she’s coming out to the show’s foxy-rich-guy-athlete, a character who’s usually a live threat to teen lesbian girls in fiction and real life.
Beyond that symbolic violence, Robin's desire never belonged to her, serving instead as Steve's character development, teaching him that not every girl exists for his romantic consumption. Her coming out facilitated his growth, making her the Manic Pixie Dream Gay Girl, existing through all of season three to make a straight man more emotionally literate.
Season 5 repeated the pattern with even less subtlety. Robin's relationship with Vickie existed primarily so Will Byers could witness homosexual happiness and find courage to come out himself. Once Will came out, Robin and Vickie apparently broke up off-screen, and Vickie vanished from the epilogue entirely.
The Duffers' response? "What percentage of couples stay together after college? Extremely low." A shrug, a footnote, a statistic deployed to justify why the show's only explicit lesbian relationship got discarded the moment it finished serving the male narratives.
Meanwhile, Will gets a full coming-out arc, magical superpowers tied to his homosexuality, emotional validation from every character, and an epilogue scene flirting with a guy at a bar showing romantic possibility.
Robin is one of Stranger Thing’s leaders, but her desire is only a plot device to facilitate men's growth. Will's desire: transformative, heroic, rewarded with powers and a future.
The Bathroom Scene That Wasn't Hers
Season 3, Episode 7. Robin and Steve are trapped in a bathroom, convinced they're about to die from a Russian truth serum. Steve confesses he likes Robin, and she laughs—not cruel, just desperate—and tells him she didn't like Steve staring at Tammy Thompson in class because she had a crush on her too.
The scene works because Maya Hawke makes it work, her delivery carrying the weight of every queer girl who's had to come out defensively, explaining why she can't give a boy what he wants while terrified he'll hate her for it.
Starting at $2 USD per month | Access to complete posts, Gorgon Posse videos, Commenting & conversation, External reading recommendations, & Special Event invitations.
First month always free.
